Home » OPINION » Columns » LAW ELEVATED — Planning for the $5-$10 Million couple: portability or credit shelter?

LAW ELEVATED — Planning for the $5-$10 Million couple: portability or credit shelter?

In 2009, each individual had a $3.5 million estate tax exemption. If a married individual had assets over $3.5 million, without careful planning, those assets in excess of $3.5 million would fall subject to a 45 percent estate tax. Careful planning often included retitling assets between spouses and utilizing a credit shelter trust (typically, a trust for the benefit of the surviving spouse and children created to hold assets equal to the remaining exemption of the first spouse to die). Additionally, if the first spouse to die did not utilize his or her exemption, whatever remained of his or her unused exemption at death was lost forever.

Print

Samantha Moore

Print

Sloane Hankins

Example one:  Harold and Wilma (married) have a combined estate of $7 million.  Harold and Wilma each have wills, which leave their entire estate outright to the surviving spouse. Wilma dies on January 1, 2009. At Wilma’s death, her entire estate passes to Harold’s estate tax free.    Harold dies on December 31, 2009. At Harold’s death, $3.5 million of his estate ($7 million less his $3.5 million exemption) is subject to estate tax at 45 percent resulting in a $1,575,000 estate tax bill. Sadly, this result could have been avoided by Harold and Wilma retitling the assets so each owned assets valued at $3.5 million and revising their wills to incorporate credit shelter trusts. If Harold and Wilma had done this, their estates would not have owed estate taxes.

To help couples like Harold and Wilma who did not plan, in 2010, Congress introduced the concept of “portability” as part of the Tax Relief, Unemployment Insurance Reauthorization and Job Creation Act of 2010 (the “2010 Act”). The 2010 Act sunset in 2012, but Congress made portability permanent in early 2013 as a part of the American Taxpayer Relief Act of 2012 (the “2012 Act”), which also permanently fixed the estate tax rate at 40 percent. The 2012 Act also permanently fixed the estate tax exemption amount at $5 million, indexed annually for inflation.  The 2016 estate tax exemption is $5.45 million.

Note that the 2012 Act also fixed the individual generation-skipping transfer tax exemption amount (an extra level of tax that applies to gifts and bequests made to grandchildren and other individuals significantly younger than the donor) at $5 million, indexed annually for inflation. The 2016 generation-skipping tax exemption is $5.45 million.

Portability

Portability is the ability of a surviving spouse to utilize a deceased spouse’s unused lifetime estate tax exemption (“DSUE”). In other words, if a married couple fails to properly plan prior to the first death, the surviving spouse still has the ability to utilize the deceased spouse’s unused estate tax exemption.

Example two: Same facts as example one, except Wilma dies on January 1, 2016, and Harold dies on December 31, 2016.  At Harold’s death, he is able to use his $5.45 million exemption, and he is also able to use Wilma’s unused $5.45 million exemption. As a result, neither estate will owe estate taxes.

Relying on portability (leaving everything outright to the surviving spouse or to a marital trust) has advantages, including, primarily, simplicity.  Another advantage of relying on portability, especially in this age of rising income tax rates, is the fact the basis of assets left outright or in a marital trust for the surviving spouse will be stepped up to the fair market value of those assets on the death of the surviving spouse.

Example three: Henry and Wendy (married) have a combined estate of $10 million, consisting of assets all titled in Henry’s name. Henry and Wendy have wills that leave all of their assets outright to the surviving spouse. Henry dies on March 1, 2016.  At Henry’s death, no estate taxes are owed. Wendy dies 10 years later on March 1, 2026, at a time when the assets have appreciated at a rate of 12 percent per year to $31,058,482 and the estate tax exemption is $7 million. At Wendy’s death, her estate can use her $7 million exemption plus Henry’s DSUE amount of $5.45 million with the result that $7,443,393 of estate taxes are due ($31,058,482, less $12.45 million taxed at 40 percent). If the assets are sold immediately following Wendy’s death, no income taxes will be due because the basis in each of those assets was stepped up to the fair market value on the date of Wendy’s death.

However, relying solely on portability also comes with several disadvantages, including the fact that the DSUE amount is not indexed for inflation. Additionally, relying on portability can also be risky. For a surviving spouse to take advantage of his or her deceased spouse’s DSUE, the decease spouse’s estate must have filed an estate tax return. This is an often-overlooked requirement of portability. Additionally, if the surviving spouse remarries, the DSUE amount could be lost if the new spouse predeceases the surviving spouse. Finally, portability only applies to an individual’s estate tax exemption amount. It does not apply to an individual’s generation-skipping tax exemption amount.

Continued Use of The Credit Shelter Trust

While the relevance of the credit shelter trust has been a hot topic for the past three years, the estate planning community has come to the conclusion, while the credit shelter trust is not the gold standard it was prior to 2010, it is still a handy tool in an estate planner’s toolbox.

The credit shelter trust shields assets (including appreciation) from estate tax on the surviving spouse’s death, but does not allow for a basis step-up on those assets on the surviving spouse’s death. In other words, the decision to utilize a credit shelter trust or rely on portability is primarily a question of whether it would be cheaper to pay estate taxes or income taxes, which primarily depends on a couple’s assets. A couple with total combined assets close to $5 million and whose children intend to sell the assets following both spouses’ deaths might benefit more from portability. However, a couple with appreciating assets may benefit more from the credit shelter trust primarily because, as stated above, the DSUE amount is not indexed for inflation.

Example four: Same facts as example three except Henry and Wendy’s wills utilize the credit shelter trust by leaving an amount of assets equal to their estate tax exemption to a trust for the benefit of the surviving spouse and children and the remaining assets outright to the surviving spouse.  At Wendy’s death, the credit shelter will own assets equal to $16,926,873 ($5.45 million assuming a growth rate of 12 percent). Wendy will own $14,131,609 of assets ($10 million less $5.45 million, assuming a growth rate of 12 percent).  At Wendy’s death, her estate will owe $2,852,644 of estate taxes. If the assets are sold immediately following Wendy’s death, income taxes of $2,295,375 will be due on the assets in the credit shelter trust ($16,926,873  less $5,45 million multiplied by a 20 percent capital gains tax rate). This totals $5,148,019 in taxes. Using a credit shelter trust has saved Henry and Wendy total taxes of $2,295,375 ($7,443,393-$5,148,018).

As previously stated, portability does not apply to the generation-skipping tax exemption.  Therefore, a couple who wishes to provide significant benefits to their grandchildren may benefit more from the use of the credit shelter trust because the deceased spouse’s remaining generation-skipping tax exemption amount can be applied to the credit shelter trust.

Planning Notes

Unfortunately, since estate planners cannot predict the future, the key to a successful estate plan for couples in the $5-$10 million net worth range is flexibility. Often, this translates into incorporating techniques that allow couples to defer decision making until the death of the first spouse.

For example, if the spouses would prefer to leave assets to each other outright, planners may want to include a standby credit shelter trust (a “disclaimer trust”) so, at the death of the first spouse, the surviving spouse and his or her advisors can decide whether the surviving spouse should accept the assets outright, or, instead, place assets in a credit shelter trust.

For the couple that elects to utilize the credit shelter in their wills, many planners are including a provision that allows the trustee to grant the surviving spouse a “general power of appointment” over the credit shelter trust assets so those assets will be included in the surviving spouse’s estate at death. If needed, this will allow the assets in the credit shelter trust to receive a step up in basis.

If the spouses would prefer to leave assets to each other in marital trusts, which do not utilize the deceased spouse’s estate tax exemption amount, the will could include a provision so, at the death of the first spouse, the surviving spouse and his or her advisors could choose to have some of those assets pour into a credit shelter trust (a “Clayton QTIP”).

Finally, while the generation-skipping tax exemption amount is not portable, the “reverse QTIP” election is available to utilize the deceased spouse’s unused generation-skipping tax amount for those couples choosing to leave all of their assets to each other in marital trusts.

Closing Thoughts

Portability, while allowing more estate planning flexibility, does create an additional level of complexity for those couples with a $5-$10 million net worth and makes planning more important than ever.

» Law Elevated is an occasional column on the latest trends, issues and perspectives facing the legal industry, written by the attorneys of Butler | Snow. For more information, visit www.butlersnow.com or follow Butler | Snow on Twitter @Butler_Snow. 

BEFORE YOU GO…

… we’d like to ask for your support. More people are reading the Mississippi Business Journal than ever before, but advertising revenues for all conventional media are falling fast. Unlike many, we do not use a pay wall, because we want to continue providing Mississippi’s most comprehensive business news each and every day. But that takes time, money and hard work. We do it because it is important to us … and equally important to you, if you value the flow of trustworthy news and information which have always kept America strong and free for more than 200 years.

If those who read our content will help fund it, we can continue to bring you the very best in news and information. Please consider joining us as a valued member, or if you prefer, make a one-time contribution.

Click for more info

About Contributing Columnist

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*