Home » NEWS » Economic Development » HB 1523 could keep MSU, Ole Miss and USM from hosting baseball regionals

HB 1523 could keep MSU, Ole Miss and USM from hosting baseball regionals

Teams could pull out of scheduled NCAA events this spring because of new state laws in North Carolina, Mississippi and Tennessee while the sport’s governing body’s demands for discrimination-free environments at the places where its events are held won’t take effect until the fall.

Though there are many potential unknowns before the measure takes effect, 27 NCAA championships are scheduled this spring and some state laws are already on the books and the decisions go beyond coaches and athletic departments.

Minnesota state university system banned its athletic teams from traveling to tournaments in North Carolina, which passed a law that opponents say can allow discrimination against LGBT people. Most of the schools in that system are Division II or III schools; the University of Minnesota, a member of the Big Ten, is not one of them.

The decision means that one of the top baseball teams in Division II, St. Cloud State — ranked No. 3 in one of the top 25 polls — will likely stay home and forgo the opportunity to reach its first Division II World Series later this month in Cary, North Carolina.

Minnesota Gov. Mark Dayton said system leaders are in the process of reconsidering the ban, and St. Cloud State President Earl Potter is hopeful a resolution is reached.

He said in a statement Wednesday that the school will “not engage in any speculation at this point” because the NCAA “is tracking this situation and is working to determine how many teams might be affected by such bans.”

Minnesota State-Mankato, which has advanced to Cary four times since 2010, also is part of that system of schools.

“This is something that is beyond our control at this point, so you trust that the people making those decisions have made them for the right reasons,” coach Matt Magers said.

The NCAA will require sites hosting or bidding on both its predetermined and merit-based events to show how they will provide an environment that is “safe, healthy and free from discrimination.”

Spokeswoman Stacey Osburn said the NCAA is looking for the best way to implement the measure.

What they decide is a concern for people like Scott Dupree, the executive director of the Greater Raleigh Sports Alliance. His group helps with the bidding on and organizing of sporting events in the North Carolina Triangle. He said organizations that host or bid on games will have to complete a form from the NCAA outlining its anti-discrimination requirements.

“The question is, what specifically is that form going to require of cities and hosts, and is that something we’ll be capable of meeting?” Dupree said. “I know they’ll ask that we guarantee a championship environment that is free of discrimination. And of course we have been doing that in the past, for years, with no problem. We have a proven record in that regard.

“But what if the NCAA comes back to us and says, ‘Well you’re promising all of this, but the fact is you still have a law on the books that allows for discrimination.’ That’s my concern,” Dupree added.

In adopting its measure, the NCAA said it was following the actions of legislatures in several states but did not identify them. In addition to North Carolina, Mississippi and Tennessee have passed similar laws.

The anti-discrimination policy seems to close a loophole in previous NCAA directives.

Though schools were not allowed to host predetermined events if their state governments flew the Confederate battle flag, schools in those states — Mississippi and South Carolina, until it took down the flag last year — were able to host to the merit-based, non-predetermined events like the FCS playoffs and baseball regionals.

Officials at the University of Memphis, the host for the 2017 men’s basketball South Regional, say the NCAA will determine if a new Tennessee law will affect those plans. Gov. Bill Haslam signed a bill that allows mental health counselors to refuse to treat patients based on the therapist’s religious or personal beliefs.

In Mississippi, a law goes into effect July 1 that will allow government workers, religious groups and some private businesses to cite religious beliefs to deny services to LGBT people. Three universities in the state — Mississippi State, Ole Miss and Southern Miss — have some of the nation’s top baseball teams and could be in line to host NCAA regionals next month.

North Carolina State also features one of the nation’s top college baseball teams, playing in the state at the center of the issue.

Gov. Pat McCrory signed a bill that prevents local governments from passing their own anti-discrimination rules covering the use of public accommodations. That came in response to Charlotte leaders approving a measure that allowed transgender people to use the restroom aligned with their gender identity. The law blocks local and state protections for LGBT people and takes away people’s ability to use state law to sue over workplace discrimination.

Supporters have defended the law as a common-sense measure that keeps men from using women’s restrooms. North Carolina Republican House Speaker Tim Moore said the NCAA should interpret it to “see that this bill is in no way discriminatory.”

A showdown is looming. In the 2016-17 academic year, at least six NCAA events are scheduled to be played in North Carolina, the highest profile being the first round of the men’s basketball tournament in Greensboro.

The law also has led to a public and business backlash that goes beyond the NCAA.

The NBA could move the 2017 All-Star game out of Charlotte. Performers from Bruce Springsteen to Pearl Jam have canceled shows out of protest, and Paypal called off plans to create an operations center in Charlotte that would have employed 400 people.


… we’d like to ask for your support. More people are reading the Mississippi Business Journal than ever before, but advertising revenues for all conventional media are falling fast. Unlike many, we do not use a pay wall, because we want to continue providing Mississippi’s most comprehensive business news each and every day. But that takes time, money and hard work. We do it because it is important to us … and equally important to you, if you value the flow of trustworthy news and information which have always kept America strong and free for more than 200 years.

If those who read our content will help fund it, we can continue to bring you the very best in news and information. Please consider joining us as a valued member, or if you prefer, make a one-time contribution.

Click for more info

About Associated Press


  1. In Mississippi, the just-passed House Bill 1523 says people can deny services or goods for the “celebration or recognition of any marriage, based upon or in a manner consistent with a sincerely held religious belief or moral conviction,” which would include pre-ceremony celebrations, post-wedding celebrations, anniversary celebrations and other related celebrations. It isn’t about just weddings, it is about ANYTHING that acknowledges the legal right of Gay couples to marry in Mississippi.

    It will be interesting to see which government agency in Mississippi concludes that the owner of a bakery can turn away a couple that wants a wedding cake, but also concludes that a restaurant cannot turn away the same couple, 20 years from now, who wish to have an anniversary dinner party. What constitutional standard will be used to determine this?

    It will also be interesting to see how judges and courts determine which cases of discrimination are motivated by “religious freedom,” and which are motivated by simple animus. Do we simply take the business owner’s word for it? And if the baker is an Atheist who doesn’t like Gay marriage, is he out of luck?

    Can this bill also be used to turn away Muslim or Atheist couples? It goes without saying that there is a great deal of animosity toward Muslims among evangelical Christians these days. If a Christian florist, for example, refused to provide flowers for a Muslim couple’s wedding, saying that to do so would be an “endorsement” of Islam, will the law in Mississippi allow her to refuse service?

    The bill ALSO permits any taxpayer-funded government official to turn away Gay couples who are seeking a marriage license, as long as the official uses his “religious freedom” as an excuse. Imagine your tax dollars paying the salary of someone who discriminates against YOU.

  2. Once again we are embarrassing and isolating ourselves from the rest of the nation just as we did 50 years ago. The economic damage is incalculable. As companies quietly drop MS from their investment lists so they will not get into a controversy with their employees, we encounter unknowable damage–but a huge effect to be sure on our economy. Are we always going to let the pandering demagogues who damage our economic prospects have control? We need new and different leadership than we have been getting. Mississippi can not be an isolated island and improve our standing.

  3. NCAA is forcing its belief standard on the people of those states. As more states follow the will of the people the ncaa may find itself without a place to go.

    • The NCAA isn’t forcing its belief on anyone, yet the stupid individuals in those states legislatures are. They have plenty of places to go.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *