Gap between school funding formula, appropriation widening

JACKSON — The gap between the state’s school funding formula and money actually being appropriated could widen past $300 million next year, raising new questions about the formula’s future.

Interim state Superintendent Lynn House told legislative budgeters the Mississippi Adequate Education Program will need $300.6 million more in the 2014 budget year than it received this year to reach full funding. The formula was $260 million short this year.

The state Department of Education requested a total of $2.4 billion, most of which flows to the state’s 151 school districts.

Some members of the Legislative Budget Committee suggested it was time for major surgery on the formula, which has been fully in effect for 10 years. However, both Lt. Gov Tate Reeves and House Appropriations Committee chairman Herb Frierson, R-Poplarville, said they were interested in less dramatic changes.

The Department of Education is required by law to ask for the full allocation, even though House quickly made clear she didn’t expect lawmakers to appropriate that amount.

House said schools could, for example, use more money to add prekindergarten classes, hire more reading tutors and help teachers improve. But she sympathized with lawmakers unhappy with the gap

“Stop making us come to the table every year and ask for something you’re not going to fund,” she said. “I would prefer that it get fixed so we’re talking about a reasonable request.”

Lawmakers appropriated $500,000 this year to hire consultants for a fresh study of the formula, but decided instead just to consult with Department of Education staff members. Frierson said he and Reeves have asked a series of questions.

“We’re picking it apart to understand how it works,” he said.

Sen. Terry Brown, R-Columbus, suggested it was time to scrap the formula, which was created to guarantee that Mississippi’s school districts get enough money. The Legislature has only fully funded the formula twice.

“I just wonder if it isn’t time for this committee and this Legislature to scrap this MAEP deal so these guys can bring in a realistic budget,” Brown said. “I don’t see us ever fully funding MAEP because it’s one of those moving targets.”

House Finance Committee Chairman Jeff Smith, R-Columbus, told House that there’s just not enough money after the state pays for K-12 schools, colleges, universities and Medicaid to appropriate another $300 million.

Frierson indicated that smaller changes might ease the situation. For example, because the formula declines when budgets go down, recalculating it every year would cut the amount demanded. Since 2005, the formula has only been recalculated every four years. Todd Ivey, bureau manager for the Office of School Financial Services, said the formula amount would fall when it’s recalculated next year.

Reeves emphasized that the Legislature had put $30 million more into K-12 schools last year when funding was falling elsewhere in the budget. He said he anticipated “a strong effort to see increased funding.”

House Speaker Pro Tem Greg Snowden, R-Meridian, wants a way to use funding to communicate legislative priorities.

“We need to take a look at getting something that works,” Snowden said.

 

[RSS Feed] [del.icio.us]



To sign up for Mississippi Business Daily Updates, click here.

One Response to “Gap between school funding formula, appropriation widening”

  1. Elaine Vechorik Says:

    Pre-kindergarten: no long-term benefits

    The Mississippi Department of Education asked for $2.5 million to create 25 prekindergarten (pre-k) programs, to prepare children for kindergarten. Pre-k programs are incredibly expensive, costing about twice what we now spend per student in K-12. While some pre-k children start kindergarten stronger, the benefits fade by the third grade or earlier. Research shows no ending improvement from such state-sponsored preschool programs.

    Oklahoma has the largest state-run pre-k program in the country. Reading scores for the 4th and 8th grades fell from above the national average to below the national average since the program’s inception.

    One of the highest pre-school enrollment rates in the country is in Washington, D.C. Yet, the percentage of 4th graders reading at or above the proficient level is consistently the lowest in the nation.

    Georgia was the earliest adopter of public pre-schools. Georgia’s kindergarten assessment program found that children placed in pre-k did no better in kindergarten than children who had not attended pre-k.

    The most comprehensive study of the Head Start program found small initial gains on IQ and other cognitive measures, that disappeared by the 2nd grade compared to children not in Head Start.

    In Tennessee, the nonpartisan Strategic Research Group found no statistical performance improvement between preschooled children and children who received no preschooling.

    Everyone wants good schools. While it’s important for school children to start well, it’s more important for them to end well. In almost every study of early childhood programs, good long-term results are not found.

    The Mississippi school system desperately needs improvement. Research shows that expensive pre-k programs are not the magic-bullet we need to improve our school system. It’s common sense to not waste taxpayer money on failed school programs.

POST A COMMENT

 

Twang & Tourism: The Country Music Trail

Our annual "Come See Us" magazine offers ideas for spots in Mississippi ranging from golf to culture to history to food. Click the photo for ideas, stories and access to the digital edition of this year's magazine.

Still planning that summer vacation?

Our annual "Come See Us" magazine offers ideas for spots in Mississippi ranging from golf to culture to history to food. Click the photo for ideas, stories and access to the digital edition of this year's magazine.

FOLLOW THE MBJ ON TWITTER

Top Posts & Pages

%d bloggers like this: