DMR employee’s house searched; pols give back money
Published: January 25,2013
Tags: auditor, campaign donation, foundation, investigate, investigation, investigator, law enforcement, media, misappropriation, newspaper, open records, political campaign, political donation, Politics, search, state agency
BILOXI — Investigators have searched the home of Tina Shumate, coastal management and planning director at the Mississippi Department of Marine Resources.
David Huggins, who heads the Investigative Audit Division of the State Auditor’s Office, tells The Sun Herald a search warrant was served at Shumate’s home Tuesday.
Huggins would not release any details about the search, part of an ongoing investigation into spending at the DMR under former director Bill Walker.
Shumate’s attorney, Tim Holleman, said investigators took routine financial records and other documents from Shumate’s home. He did not want to detail the records confiscated.
Holleman said he believes the investigation will clear his client of any wrongdoing.
In November, a federal audit questioned the DMR’s purchase of property owned by Shumate’s parents.
In a separate but related item, campaigns for governor, Congress, the state Legislature and other offices received checks from the foundation headed by Walker.
Recently, campaigns have begun giving the money back, as the state and federal investigations into the MDMR’s spending practices under Walker’s leadership are continuing.
The activities of the Mississippi Marine Resources Foundation, which was created in 2004, under the premise it would support the activities of the MDMR, have also been placed under scrutiny. Public money from the MDMR has flowed through the foundation, but how much isn’t clear.
Walker was fired by the MDMR’s governing board earlier this month, and since then, some checks from his foundation were given back. Others were never accepted for various reasons. It’s unknown how many candidates received money and how much was spent. Walker has not been available for comment.
Gov. Phil Bryant’s campaign told the Sun Herald it has refunded the $500 it received from the foundation in 2010 and the $1,000 the group gave it in 2011.
“These were legal contributions accepted in compliance with campaign finance laws,” a statement from Friends of Phil Bryant treasurer Paul Breazeale said. “Given the recent news questioning the financial activity of that foundation, we decided to voluntarily return the total amount to the foundation on Jan. 18, 2013.”
The Sun Herald has reported the Investigative Audit Division of the State Auditor’s Office and the FBI are investigating the MDMR’s spending under Walker’s leadership. The U.S. Interior Department recently audited the agency.
The Sun Herald also has written about the foundation, which owns two recreational fishing boats — a 36-foot Topaz sport fisherman and a 42-foot Californian convertible.
Some have questioned spending hundreds of thousands of public dollars repairing and upgrading the boats. The fishing trips the MDMR has taken lawmakers and other influential folks on have been questioned as well.
The MDMR spent more than $1.46 million out of a Rigs to Reefs program fund on upgrades, maintenance and insurance for the two boats the foundation owns.
The MDMR defends the use of the boats, which it leases from the foundation, saying they are used to educate people through fishing trips to artificial reefs the agency maintains.
Documents the Sun Herald received show other public money has been given to the foundation through thousands in environmental violation fines.
In addition to being treasurer for Bryant’s campaign, Breazeale, of Jackson, is treasurer of U.S. Rep. Steven Palazzo’s campaign, which has also refunded money to the foundation. Palazzo’s campaign received a foundation check for $250 in February, and it was returned last week, Breazeale said.
U.S. Sen. Roger Wicker’s campaign received a check for $300 it wouldn’t accept.
The foundation, which was incorporated in 2004, is listed as a nonprofit corporation in good standing with the Secretary of State’s Office. Federal campaign-finance law doesn’t allow direct contributions from corporations to candidates for federal office. Wicker’s campaign manager, Ryan Annison, said the $300 check written June 27 was given back to the foundation.
“Wicker for Senate can’t accept donations of this kind and never deposited the check from (the foundation),” Annison said.
U.S. Sen. Thad Cochran’s office said it has no record of having ever received any money from the foundation.
State Sen. Michael Watson, R-Pascagoula, said he received either $200 or $250 from the foundation at a campaign fundraiser at a home in Pascagoula in the fall. He told the Sun Herald on Wednesday he plans to give the money back, or give it to a charity.
“I don’t plan to keep that money in my account,” Watson said.
Former State Sen. Billy Hewes is running for mayor of Gulfport. He said the foundation tried to give him a check as part of fundraising golf tournament he held last year, but he didn’t accept it because it came from a foundation. He couldn’t recall the amount, but said he would likely return any money from a foundation.
“We just figured it didn’t fit in with the normal contributions, so we returned it,” Hewes said.
Hewes, who also ran for lieutenant governor, said he doesn’t recall getting any money from the foundation for his campaigns.
Websites that report campaign finances have limited information about the foundation’s donations, and the latest state finance reports aren’t due until the end of the month. The Federal Elections Commission, which oversees federal elections, has no record in its system of any donations from the foundation.
A full accounting of the foundation’s spending hasn’t yet been given, so it’s unclear how much was spent on campaigns and exactly which candidates received the money.
The Sun Herald made a public records request to the MDMR this week to get details of political contributions the foundation made, but the agency hasn’t yet responded. Under state law, the agency has up to seven working days to comply with most requests and up to 14 days in some cases involving more-complicated requests.
Commission on Marine Resources Chairman Vernon Asper, said the commission, which oversees the MDMR, was unaware of the donations.
“As you know, none of the commissioners were involved in any of the foundation activities, so I’m confident that none of us knew anything about these donations,” Asper said.
Finally, the DMR has agreed to turn over some financial records to a Gulf Coast newspaper.
The Sun Herald had sued the agency in Harrison County Chancery Court. The newspaper had requested records related to MDMR’s disaster relief and artificial reef accounts.
The Sun Herald reports the two sides had been scheduled to be in court today for a hearing.
The MDMR had said a subpoena from the State Auditor’s Office prohibited the agency from releasing the records to others. A judge agreed this week to modify the subpoena so the MDMR could release the records.
Sun Herald attorney Henry Laird says the newspaper will be allowed to inspect and copy them in the near future.
To sign up for Mississippi Business Daily Updates, click here.
FOLLOW THE MBJ ON TWITTERMy Tweets
Top Posts & Pages
- Voters to decide whether hunting, fishing is constitutional right
- Dak Prescott's autograph fetches a pretty penny
- Gulf oil and gas leases to go up for sale in March
- Grand juries charge seven with election violations
- Butler Snow names Crockoft new office director
- Farm theft investigation recovers $200K in stolen equipment
- Airport gets grant to support seasonal service from Sun Country
- State officials identify first flu case this season
- STAYING POSITIVE — Career attitude help Brynn Joachim to fight disease at 41