Bad bridges list draws strong reaction
by Wally Northway
Published: June 28,2013
Few people know Jones County better than Mitch Stennett, a long-time resident and head of the Economic Development Authority of Jones County.
Yet, even he was surprised by the number of suspect bridges in his county and where they are located per the National Bridge Inventory (NBI).
“Two bridges on the Ellisville-Tuckers Crossing Road are on the list? Really?” Stennett asked. “That is a heavily traveled road.” When he learned that the NBI has red-flagged 46 bridges in Jones County and thousands across the state, he added, “I am surprised by that. I had no idea it was that many. I guess it is out of sight, out of mind.”
Patrice O’Brien lives in Rankin County, but she owns timberland in Yalobusha County and has witnessed firsthand the challenges bad bridges create. A creek running along her Yalobusha land was dredged in a flood control project. The dredging caused enormous erosion issues, and eventually damaged a neighboring farmer’s bridge.
“He came to me asking permission to use the bridge on my property because he could no longer get to market,” O’Brien said. “For those of us in the agriculture industry, safe, dependable roads and bridges are absolutely essential.”
Their reaction to the list of aging bridges in Mississippi that get a low grade in the NBI is typical. The Mississippi Business Journal ran the entire list of more than 2,000 bridges in the June 21 issue, and it has drawn sharp comments.
“This is what we’re trying to do — get the word out that we have a growing problem in Mississippi, and that we need to address it now,” said Mike Pepper, executive director of the Mississippi Road Builders Association, when presented MBJ’s list. “Sometimes the numbers — thousands of bridges and billions of dollars needed to fix them — are just too big to get your mind around.”
The bridges in the NBI, which are available on the Office of State Aid Road Construction’s website at www.msstateaidroads.us, are ranked on a sufficiency rating scale of 0-100. Information on individual bridges includes the roadway, feature intersected, year built, bridge type, year rehabilitated or repaired, the entity that owns the bridge, average daily traffic, etc. It also provides a rating on each bridge’s deck, superstructure, substructure, culvert and channel.
The NBI list does not include the 1,054 suspect state bridges — structures either closed or posted — that are maintained by the Mississippi Department of Transportation. (The MBJ ran a complete list of the state’s posted bridges in the June 14 issue.)
County supervisors are responsible for the upkeep of the vast majority of the bridges in the NBI, and they face a growing problem daily. More people seeking country living and new business and industry is putting more and more traffic on roads that only a few years ago were relatively little-used rural lanes. Counties really felt the crunch two years ago when the Legislature did not pass a bond bill.
Melinda McGrath, executive director of MDOT, has personally seen — and heard — supervisors’ problems. A rural Hinds County road she lives on has become a shortcut to the industrial park in Clinton. She also was on the Coast last week where the supervisors met to discuss major issues, transportation infrastructure being a key talking point.
“They need more funding — everybody is looking for money,” McGrath said succinctly when asked what she heard from supervisors.
McGrath said MDOT-managed bridges are part of the grid and are better maintained than the county and municipal bridges. She said non-MDOT bridges, while on average shorter, are also generally older.
“These are largely old, wooden structures,” McGrath said. “I would guess that the majority of the bridges (that are red-flagged in the NBI) are beyond rehabilitation — they need to be replaced.”
MDOT, the transportation commissioners, road-builders, foresters and more have been trying to call attention to the growing bad bridge issue, and gain some political traction. At the heart of the effort is to replace the current funding mechanism — set in 1987 at $18 cents per gallon of fuel.
Last year, legislation in the State House that would have raised the tax failed to get out of committee. The Senate briefly explored a plan that would have used a portion of casino winnings for bridge and road costs, which was never formally debated, before passing a resolution to form a study group to explore the issues. (The group met for the first time June 12.)
In the meantime, concerns continue to rise that the states deteriorating bridges are going to stymie economic development and offer a real threat to public safety.
Perhaps Robby Toombs of Resource Management Service, LLC, in Flowood summoned it up best. He has been active on the road and bridges front in Mississippi for years. Recently, he worked as part of a team developing the Mississippi Forestry Association’s position statement on the issue.
“In my opinion, Mississippi’s two greatest assets are its people and land,” Toombs said, adding that bad bridges are a threat to both.
For the MBJ’s complete list of red-flagged bridges that ran in the June 21 issue, visit http://bit.ly/183mo1r. For a list of the state’s posted bridges that ran in the June 14 issue, visit http://bit.ly/11FknEA.
>>Mississippi’s Worst Bridges
Of the 2,000-plus bridges given a sufficiency rating of 50 or less in the National Bridge Inventory, where are the absolutely worst bridges in Mississippi?
Bridge, County, Year Built, Sufficiency Rating
CR 144 over Abiaca Creek Carroll 1930 .0
Lee Ave. over Illinois Central Gulf R.R. Forrest 1939 .0
Old River Rd. over Tallahala Creek Perry 1956 2.0
Jacinto Rd. over Tuscumbia River Prentiss 1967 3.0
Manhattan Rd. over Hanging Moss Creek Hinds (city of Jackson) 1964 3.0
Ramp to field near Ballentine Rd. over drainage Prentiss 1963 3.0
Lower Woodville Rd. over St. Catherine’s Creek Adams 1945 4.0
Old Hwy. 80 over Big Black River Hinds 1929 4.0
Frank Seal Rd. over Parker Bayou Pearl River 1964 4.8
CR 46 over Tallahatchie River relief Union 1963 6.0
CR 561 over unnamed branch Neshoba (city of Philadelphia) 1940 6.0
Darling Rd. over Wilson Bayou Quitman 1955 6.1
CR 46 over Tallahatchie River Union 1971 6.8
Ellisville-Tuckers Crossing Rd. over Flat Branch Jones 1957 7.0
Hanging Moss Rd. over Hanging Moss Creek tributary Hinds (city of Jackson) 1987 7.0
James St. over Burkett’s Creek Forrest (city of Hattiesburg) 1965 7.0
Kiln-DeLisle Rd. over Bayou Le Terre Hancock 1960 7.0
Rocky Hill Dedeaux over Bayou Le Terre Hancock 1966 7.0
Rocky Hill Dedeaux over Bayou Le Terre tributary Hancock 1966 7.0
Lowe’s Rd. over Main Canal Washington (city of Greenville) 1954 8.0
Old Hwy. 145/Tate St. over Elam Creek Alcorn 1970 8.4
Otho Sellers Rd. over Sand Hill Creek Perry 1905 8.6
Pineville Rd. over Canal No. 1 Harrison (city of Long Beach) 1971 8.6
CR 600 over Hatchie River Alcorn 1953 8.7
CR 46 over Tallahatchie River slough Union 1964 8.9
Will Garrett Rd. over Toomsuba Creek Lauderdale 1929 9.7
Note: Does not include railroad bridges
To sign up for Mississippi Business Daily Updates, click here.
Top Posts & Pages
- Lost Pizza discovered — Restaurateurs begin franchising
- Conservator: Schools had too many employees
- IKE TROTTER: There are primary changes in Social Security for 2014
- PSC unanimously rejects Entergy-ITC proposed merger
- Company mulling plan to build new pipeline
- Study says state sacrificing billions of dollars, 20,000 jobs in refusing Medicaid expansion
- Omega Protein shifting vessels to Mississippi
- Keeping our eye on ... Laurel Donahoo
- Bankrupt Simply Wheelz chooses prevailing bidder for assets