Home » NEWS » Energy » Mississippi groups attack carbon dioxide limits, say unreasonable

Mississippi groups attack carbon dioxide limits, say unreasonable

Global-warming-photo-lester-brown-2JACKSON — Mississippi regulators and utilities are savaging the federal government’s proposal to force Mississippi power plants to cut carbon dioxide emissions.

In comments filed in December, leaders of utilities, state agencies and business groups called the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s Clean Power Plan illegal, infeasible and economically unbearable.

The EPA announced specific targets for all the states in June, accepting comments through Dec. 1, with plans to finalize the rule in 2015. The proposal calls for Mississippi’s power plants to emit 38 percent less carbon dioxide in 2030 than in 2005.

In a Mississippi fact sheet released in June, the Obama administration said the plan would help Mississippi improve health by cutting asthma, as well as stabilizing the climate to prevent harmful changes in the weather. A number of environmental groups are supporting the effort.

“The Environmental Protection Agency’s proposed Clean Power Plan for existing power plants will cut carbon pollution and save thousands of lives a year while strengthening our power grid and keeping electricity affordable,” the Natural Resources Defense Council wrote in October.

But almost all the Mississippi respondents claimed EPA was overstepping its legal authority.

“EPA is attempting to federalize this nation’s energy policy, resulting in forcing the states to abandon their constitutionally derived sovereign rights,” wrote Gary Rikard, executive director of the Mississippi Department of Environmental Quality. “EPA hides behind a fig leaf of federalism and flexibility while in effect forcing major changes to the states’ administration of electricity generation and consumption.”

Rikard was appointed by Gov. Phil Bryant, who signed a letter with 14 other Republican governors opposing the plan. Bryant favors letting states set their own energy policy.

EPA said Mississippi could choose how to meet the goal. But opponents say that claim of flexibility is a mirage. They note EPA’s own projections show all of Mississippi’s existing coal-fired plants will have to close to meet the target. Even then, though, it may be impossible because EPA’s proposed emission rates are below those released by existing natural gas plants.

“It is not possible for Mississippi to rely on gas-fired generation to manage the challenges of increasing the levels of renewable energy and energy efficiency,” wrote the Mississippi Public Service Commission.

Emissions in Mississippi are already below national averages because the state depends on natural gas and nuclear generation. But Mississippi would have to cut emissions more than the nationwide projected cut of 30 percent, said Michael Callahan, CEO of Electric Power Associations of Mississippi.

“The CO2 emission goals set for Mississippi by EPA are unreasonable, unachievable and unfair,” Callahan wrote.

Mississippi regulators said the state has little ability to generate electricity from windmills or hydroelectric dams. They also said the state isn’t getting credit for earlier reductions and new efficiency efforts.

Mississippi Power Co. parent Southern Co. wrote that the plan would produce “intolerably high compliance costs and customer rate increases,” and multiple commenters cited a $14.2 billion cost figure from the Mississippi Energy Institute. South Mississippi Electric Power Association, which buys and generates electricity for 11 cooperatives, warned the rule could financially cripple the organization

Even Entergy Corp., which has made reducing carbon dioxide emissions a part of its corporate strategy since 2001, called on the EPA to withdraw the proposal.

“Entergy is stating that this complex issue should be managed through a comprehensive national energy policy that is also beyond EPA’s authority, and, indeed, beyond the rational provenance of an administrative rulemaking,” wrote Chuck Barlow, Entergy’s vice president of environmental strategy and policy.


… we’d like to ask for your support. More people are reading the Mississippi Business Journal than ever before, but advertising revenues for all conventional media are falling fast. Unlike many, we do not use a pay wall, because we want to continue providing Mississippi’s most comprehensive business news each and every day. But that takes time, money and hard work. We do it because it is important to us … and equally important to you, if you value the flow of trustworthy news and information which have always kept America strong and free for more than 200 years.

If those who read our content will help fund it, we can continue to bring you the very best in news and information. Please consider joining us as a valued member, or if you prefer, make a one-time contribution.

Click for more info

About Megan Wright


  1. Coal fired electrical generation is one of the worst greenhouse gas polluters there is. The EPA’s mission is to address pollution issues. Science and the courts have determined that our excessive CO2 pollution needs to be regulated as pollution. This is well established.

    No one said that this was going to be easy. It’s extremely complex but since the coal fired generators are the worst offenders they should be the first to change despite their well-funded lobby efforts to the contrary.

    Join the efforts to change course for the sake of our future generations.

  2. 美少女!素晴らしい記事 非常に信じられないほど本当に | これがしたこれはされています。 これらの詳細を 。
    Hot高級品 一部予約販売 http://familywealth.ca

Leave a Reply